You know there's a problem when it takes 11 years to prove that the last album wasn't as bad as you remember, at least not compared to the latest offering.
The time has come to stop calling Tom Scholz a genius. The debut Boston album was genius. But that was when Boston was a band. It has been a case of diminishing returns ever since and 6 albums in 37 years is really quite a pathetic work rate.
Scholz is his own worst enemy. It seems he takes advice from no one, works almost entirely on his own and doesn't listen to any other artists, has a habit of rehashing songs despite decades between projects and even though he performs live with a kick ass band, doesn't utilize any of their abilities when it comes to recording.
The whole Boston conundrum just gives me a headache thinking about it. What a good A&R guy could do if Scholz was ever ready to listen.
Boston the band morphed into the Tom Scholz machine shortly after the second album and by the time Corporate America finally arrived in 2002, Boston was all but a one man band. Sadly that problem has only intensified on Life, Love & Hope.
To step back a bit – the machines were beginning to take over the band during the Walk On recording years and what little momentum the name Boston had was again lost in taking another 8 years to deliver Corporate America.
Corporate America featured a few killer songs (I Had A Good Time, Stare Out Your Window, You Gave Up On Love, Didn't Mean To Fall In Love), but some appalling ones too (With You, Cryin', Turn It Off – yes please!).
What frustrates the hell out of me as a fan (I am) is the repeated mistakes. The at times annoying drum sound on CA is only magnified on L, L & H – this time becoming the only drums used. That's right – nothing but Scholz delivered drum programming and tinny sounding cymbals here.
And without doubt, the absolutely biggest WTF moment Boston's long history was Kimberly Dahme's country song With You being included on Corporate America – and in such a prominent position.
So does Tom Scholz learn from that? No…instead Kimberly is back for an increased presence on the new album, but at least no country tune. But Boston for me is never going to include a female lead vocal.
Fans were also not happy that CA took 8 years and produced only 9 new tracks, as Living' For You was brought back for a second run. Why? There's simply no need. If you can't get a song right in 6 years, then move on!
When Scholz was complaining again over the lack of impact CA had back when released in 2002 (label's fault of course!), he was talking about reworking a few of that album's tracks and adding a few new songs for a second take on that album. That was about 8 years back.
I heard nothing of that since, so when the years rolled by without any new product, it seemed safe to assume Tom had come to his senses, realized fans just didn't like the album overall and dropped the stupid idea to concentrate on just writing the best all-new Boston album possible.
When the announcement came that the new album was actually finished and was to be released in 2013, I was quietly hopeful that the material would warrant the longest gap between Boston albums yet – 11 years.
So I was absolutely shocked and totally disappointed to hear that not 1 or 2, but 3 of CA's tracks were still going to be reprised on Life, Love & Hope.
And one of those isn't even rerecorded! Didn't Mean To Fall In Love is a simple cut and paste from Corporate America. I just don't get that! At. All.
Same fans, same audience, same people buying the albums. No need to repeat yourself. Am I being too cynical to think that this track is included just to be able to have the late, great Brad Delp included more in the credits?
The other two rehashed tracks are Someone and You Gave Up On Love, which in all honesty, have not been improved upon in the 11 years since their original release.
Someone of course features the great Delp on lead vocals and hasn't been tampered with apart from the awful drum programming. Again, I think this is a wonderful song, but its presence here seems merely filling the Delp quota.
You Gave Up On Love (2.0) now features Kimberley Dahme in a prominent lead vocal role (why????) and lead vocals also from Tommy Decarlo and Tom Scholz.
That leaves us with the result of 11 years of work - 8 new songs.
So let's talk Life, Love & Hope.
The Scholz one man band approach has resulted in a couple of things.
First – the lack of a real drummer is beyond comprehension. The programmed beats are beyond annoying and repetitive without any of the soul of feel that a human being brings to the process.
Secondly – the mix is awful. That's the most unforgivable aspect of the album – 11 years in the making and it features the worst production of any Boston album.
Third – the overall tempo of the album is very laid back. Every Boston album has been that little bit mellower than the last and this is no exception.
Lastly – the song sequencing is ridiculous.
The album starts in almost identical fashion to Corporate America – a nice uptempo AOR anthem. David Victor does a nice lead vocal and is then criminally discarded for the remainder of the album. Vocalist Louis St. August (Mass) appears for a brief vocal line – he could have been used more also.
But to cut and paste Didn't Mean To Fall In Love as the second track is just silly. But then it gets truly ludicrous as Sholz figures after one new track and one old track, fans would love nothing more than to hear him deliver an attention seeking instrumental. No sir, that is not the case.
The one new track to feature a new Brad Delp lead vocal is Sail On, a dramatic mid-tempo track with an ok chorus, but an odd sounding Delp vocal to be honest. Kimberley Dahme again appears on lead vocals in and around the track, which is a little off-putting and the track just kind of comes to a stop without warning. Odd.
Life, Love, & Hope is a pretty decent tune featuring Tommy Decarlo on lead vocals. He is obviously in the band to cover Brad Delp's songs and on record, he also sounds close to the master vocalist. This is a free moving, uptempo melodic rocker with a decent chorus, but the drums are hideous.
If You Were in Love has potential. Unfortunately I just don't like Kimberley Dahme as a lead vocalist on this material and the verse is forgettable. The chorus is much stronger and had it been sung by David Victor, I think it could have been a pretty good AOR track.
Someday is another Tommy Decarlo sung tune, but with some additional vocals from Scholz and Dahme again on lead vocals in the bridge. I wish that wasn't the case. Otherwise it's an ok uptempo melodic rocker. Not a bad track, but really nothing we haven't heard many times before with Boston.
Love Got Away is Schulz on every instrumental and programming as usual and now lead vocals too. Yep, Tom Scholz has decided he can also sing now. Next Boston album will have him on all vocals no doubt – more elimination of needless band personnel.
At least he's a touch better than Eddie Van Halen singing. I don't like the track at all.
The final new track closes the album. The Way You Look Tonight is a slow to mid-tempo AOR number with the attempted lush Boston layering, but the mix is just awkward.
Tommy Decarlo sings again with the wasted David Victor on harmonies. This song and the opening number are probably the best two tracks on the album.
11 years, another new record label, more new vocalists, less band members than ever and just 29 minutes of newly written material. On top of that, the worst drum sound of any major artist release in recent memory, the worst production of any Boston album yet and just 3 or 4 songs that I think can stand on their own as worthy of the Boston name.
Oh, and the CD artwork is dreadful too. I doubt there will be another Boston album. Not if it's going to take until 2024 to release.
Some will be thankful for that. I, on the other hand, see the history of Boston as the greatest example of wasted time and lost opportunities in rock n roll history…so much potential and so many great songs over the years. But there could have been so any more.
Discography / Previously Reviewed
|
· Boston
· Don't Look Back
· Third Stage
· Walk On
· Corporate America
· Life, Love & Hope |
Line Up:
|
· Tommy Decarlo, David Victor, Brad Delp, Kimberly Dahme: Vocals
· Tom Scholz: Guitars, Drums, Bass, Keyboards, Vocals
|
Essential For Fans Of:
|
· Tom Scholz |
|
Track Listing
|
· Heaven on Earth *
· Didn't Mean To Fall In Love
· Last Day Of School
· Sail Away
· Life, Love & Hope *
· If You Were In Love
· Someday *
· Love Got Away
· Someone (2.0)
· You Gave Up On Love (2.0)
· The Way You Look Tonight *
--*Best Tracks |
|
|