20/01/05: Steve - stbomar@aol.com
Rating: 80
I'll give it a B just because of Steve's vocals, otherwise I'd drop the score. And that's not saying that his vocals are good here - I personally think they're simply ok. I definitely do NOT think his voice is shot because he stills sounds great live and if you check out the last Kansas CD of new material (though getting to be 5 years old at this point), as well as Device Voice Drum and Glossolalia (sp?), there is no question he still has the voice. I just think he fell short here and it could be that he just did not live with the material long enough. A couple of good moments but overall not that great.
29/07/04: Ian - Watsoni10@aol.com
Rating: 95
Once in a while an album comes out and smacks you in the face,this is it.Living With A Memory is a superb piece of quality AOR and the rest of the cd is not far behind.People have criticised Walsh about his voice,but for me,thats what makes the album.Also,Liverani excels.Brilliant.
25/06/04: Guillermo - Guillerperez@usuariosretecal.es
Rating: 80
UN album que fomenta la vision borrosa al menos para mi. LOs temas son buenos pero el conjunto queda algo por debajo. UN aceptable trabajo de hard/aor
22/08/03: freddy de keyzer - freddydekeyzer@hotmail.com
Rating: 50
The more I listen to this, the more that I'm disappointed ! Steve Walsh is not singing, but shouting ! There is so much talent here, but the result is so weak. You see, I'm not only hard for modern acts, but also for classic stars if the record is not that good. Streets and Kansas are head and shoulders aboven this project ! No variation, no surprises ! A big disappointment for me !
22/08/03: Danny - danielhayes13@hotmail.com
Rating: 65
What??!?!? Sorry to be the voice of dissent, but I really don't agree with these comments. I just really cannot get into Steve Walsh's vocals - to me they're just too dry and even sound off-key and dischordant in places. For the most part the songs are great but the Peterik songs aren't up to his normal standard IMO (and this is coming from a confirmed Peterik fan). I just kept imagining Peterik singing them and wishing they were the originals. The arrangements don't do anything for the songs - for example, while listening to Tears on the Pages you can imagine how it's "supposed to" sound (not the right phrase but you know what I mean) and the arrangement just seems to clash with the rhythm and melodies. And c'mon, there's just no comparison between Khymera's version of Bless A Brand New Angel and the Diana DeWitt/Venus & Mars version - where did all the passion and feeling go?!?!? The Mr Big songs are great but I miss Eric Martin, the Winger songs are fine-ish, and the Hardline track lacks the punch of the original band. It's a brave attempt to be sure, and an interesting collection of songs, but I was expecting so much more from this given the names involved. I'm not that familiar with Steve's work with Kansas; maybe it's just that these particular songs don't fit his vocal style? I admire the guys' courage for taking on such big names and attempting to equal performances by singers as talented as Eric Martin, Johhny Giolei, Peterik etc, but I just don't think they made it. Sorry! :-S
29/07/03: Tim Bucci - LadleyPG@aol.com
Rating: 95
I am very much impressed with this CD! The music is lush and the songs have more hooks then what you'd find in my tackle box. Honestly, there's not a bad song in the bunch! Steve does a great job singing (I've never been a huge Steve Walsh fan, but you can truly ignore the moans you've read here about his voice)! If this were 1988 in the US, at least three of these tracks would get a healthy radio rotation. This is one helluva release ... in fact, it's so good that if my music collection were stolen today, I'd be buying this CD again tomorrow. It's that good. My money was well-spent here! Great job, guys!
18/06/03: Stefan - grimbsel@aol.com
Rating: 91
The music is great, but i would like to see Joe Vana sing the song, because steve walsh voice sometimes don't fit with the music.
05/05/03: Todd - tgaudieri@amdex.com
Rating: 95
I think Steve Walsh sounds fantastic. Maybe not the same as when he was twenty but who does? He always puts more energy in his delivery making you as a listener feel the dramatic. Of course Liverani is in a league of his own. Must buy
12/04/03: Jose - joseluislopez@todito.com
Rating: 90
For me is nothing but a mayor great melodic rock showcase, just the way I love it. "Living in a Memory" alone worths the buy of this Cd.
07/04/03: Jerry - joliver2001@attbi.com
Rating: 85
The only real let-down of this album is the Randall track "Bless a Brand New Angel", which too me, should have been the highlight of the album. Instead, the vocals on that track crack and don't sound right for the song itself, especially when compared to the original version of the song by Venus & Mars. The rest of the album is good, true Steve's vocals have seen better days, but for the music, alone, this is an essential purchase for me.
ADD YOUR OWN REVIEW! (Ratings out of 100)