I don't think it's quite as woeful as many say but, having said that, it'd be my least listened to album by quite some way. Unlike most here I think Without You is an absolute shocker of a song , especially as lead single.
They're my favourite band ever and I just don't think Cherone worked for them - studio or live.
Having said that - as Shawn has pointed out what was great was the tour..
Forum:
Noticeboard