Gotthard Review
Posted by: Pressure ()
Date: April 03, 2014 02:04AM

A suggestion, not a complaint

Andrew, I'll start by saying I look forward to your reviews and appreciate the time that goes into writing a comprehensive review. The text always provides a guide I can take to heart and matches the soundbites. Even if I don't agree based on taste, I can see where you are coming from. It is the score that sometimes seems out of balance with your actual review and seems to cause the most debate.

This is not a question of whether we should agree with your review, but whether your review agrees with itself.

The Gotthard review is a prime example of where your ratings sometimes don't make a lot of sense. Reading the text of the review (without hearing the music) I would never give a score of 90, which on your scale is a MUST BUY. It reads like an upper 70's (definitely good) or low 80s (very good) score. The House of Lords is another where you were "struggling to get into it" and of the choruses "a couple don't work and a couple are a bit annoying." Yet it too gets a MUSt BUY score of 90.

It would seem like anything in the 90's should be as it says, a MUST BUY with near (obviously not unanimous, but nearly) universal appeal to those who frequent the site. The songs, execution, and production should all be great. So long as we like the style (or singer), we should love it.

I know it has been suggested many times, but perhaps with the launch of the fresh site, you would reconsider a fresh review system. A simple 5 or 10 point scale is what everyone else seems to use and is easy to understand and keep consistent.

Either way, keep up the good work.

PRESSURE

________________________________________________________________________
"It can turn a lump of coal into a flawless diamond, or an average person into a perfect basketcase." (www.despair.com)

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Gotthard Review677 Pressure 04/03/2014 02:04AM
Re: Gotthard Review 351 patiscat 04/03/2014 02:26AM
Re: Gotthard Review 470 jbjrsdc 04/03/2014 03:42AM
Re: Gotthard Review 311 JMac 04/03/2014 03:52AM
Re: Gotthard Review 319 Terry K. 04/03/2014 04:56AM
Re: Gotthard Review 381 Andrew 04/03/2014 08:25AM
Re: Gotthard Review 277 danrox 04/03/2014 12:04PM
Re: Gotthard Review 313 Andrew 04/03/2014 12:55PM
Re: Gotthard Review 297 blm 04/03/2014 08:21PM
Re: Gotthard Review 250 Laurent 04/03/2014 08:59PM
Re: Gotthard Review 221 d2cheer 04/04/2014 12:11AM
Re: Gotthard Review 213 SNorander 04/04/2014 12:36AM
Re: Gotthard Review 248 blm 04/04/2014 12:50AM
Re: Gotthard Review 202 SNorander 04/04/2014 01:55AM
Re: Gotthard Review 219 GriffonNest 04/04/2014 03:57AM
Re: Gotthard Review 185 SNorander 04/04/2014 06:15AM
Re: Gotthard Review 175 Terry K. 04/04/2014 04:03AM
Re: Gotthard Review 243 Andrew 04/04/2014 07:25AM
Re: Gotthard Review 209 Lennie 04/04/2014 05:54PM
Re: Gotthard Review 156 Terry K. 04/05/2014 04:42AM
Another suggestion Andrew.. 114 Kauna 04/06/2014 09:59AM
Re: Another suggestion Andrew.. 123 Andrew 04/06/2014 10:51AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.