RE: Just think...
Posted by: Angus ()
Date: December 01, 2000 06:26AM


So let me get this straight... we're not supposed to talk about supposed "boy bands" because even though they can all sing real well and perform some damn catchy (dare I say "melodic") songs, it's not "rock". But it's okay to dig somebody like Steve Perry or Kevin Chalfant who sing well and have catchy, melodic songs (not all of which would qualify as "rock" I might add), because of the simple fact that teenage girls don't scream at them.

Sure. THAT makes sense.

I got news for you, as much as I love the way both guys sing, there's not much that's overtly "manly" about guys like Perry and Chalfant. Does that make them queer? No. Does that make me queer for liking them? No. But the truth is they sing sappy songs about love that chicks dig and which *gasp* we do as well. How does that make them different from an N'Sync or a Backstreet Boys?

Sure, it's not "rock" in the strictest sense, but it's not THAT far removed either. And it's not as if by branching out and talking about them here on this board we're suddenly altering the kind of news Andrew gives us. It's just a thread. A topic for discussion. An interesting sidebar to a conversation. Nothing more. The whole point of this board is for people to get answers to questions as well as be able to just shoot the shit with other likeminded people about a subject near and dear to them. And that's all we're doing. So what if it gets a little off of the track in terms of what's considered "melodic rock". It's still on subject, which is music. You'd have a beef if we started talking about which guy was cuter, or if we were blabbing about the way Britney does her hair.

The ironic thing is, the conversation itself was about HOW those pop bands relate to the bands we like. It's just comparing the two styles.

Is it really necessary to mock what others wanna like or talk about? Or are you hiding something? C'mon, Koogles... admit it. "Bye Bye Bye" has a good rhythm. It's okay... you're among friends. We won't think you're gay.

-Later, Angus
NP: Matchbox 20 - Mad Season


Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 146 KAOS FAN 11/30/2000 11:30AM
NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 104 koogles 11/30/2000 01:15PM
RE: NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 148 KAOS FAN 11/30/2000 05:21PM
RE: NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 110 brent 11/30/2000 08:37PM
RE: NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 84 Mike 11/30/2000 02:01PM
Hear! Hear! 110 Rogue 11/30/2000 04:24PM
RE: NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 111ChrisJ11/30/2000 03:47PM
RE: NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 125ChrisJ11/30/2000 03:47PM
RE:Sorry for posting 97ChrisJ11/30/2000 03:49PM
RE:Sorry for posting TWICE!!! 90ChrisJ11/30/2000 04:18PM
RE: Here we go again... 96 Don 11/30/2000 06:14PM
Don, I must say that.... 89Captain Chaos11/30/2000 11:33PM
RE: LOL, Captain... 86 Don 12/01/2000 05:52AM
Me? I just think that analogy was... 102Surfpunk12/01/2000 08:59AM
RE: Oh yeah?!... 136 Don 12/01/2000 10:12AM
Basically ... 111 RAMMY 11/30/2000 07:19PM
RE: Gimme a f***ing break! 117Peter M. Bietenholz11/30/2000 10:59PM
RE: Gimme a f***ing break! 128 Stimpy 11/30/2000 11:44PM
RE: Gimme a f***ing break! 97 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 01:21AM
RE: Gimme a f***ing break! 123 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 01:20AM
Just think... 124 koogles 12/01/2000 01:31AM
RE: Just think...112 Angus 12/01/2000 06:26AM
Which guys are cuter! 139Captain Chaos12/01/2000 07:08AM
Nick is it! 106Ferrari Sparklepants12/01/2000 07:48AM
All trends do not disappear 110Captain Chaos11/30/2000 11:47PM
Here's my two cents.. spend it as you may 132 koogles 12/01/2000 12:39AM
RE: Here's my two cents.. spend it as you may 105 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 01:25AM
I think we have a 98 Degrees fan on our hands here 106 koogles 12/01/2000 01:38AM
RE: I think we have a 98 Degrees fan on our hands 106 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 02:23AM
RE: I think we have a 98 Degrees fan on our hands 145 Kevin 12/01/2000 05:41AM
If you don't stand for something... 111 koogles 12/01/2000 07:54AM
RE: If you don't stand for something... 105 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 08:15AM
RE: If you don't stand for something... 102 koogles 12/01/2000 08:28AM
RE: If you don't stand for something... 133Robert12/01/2000 08:42AM
Sorry, I've been too busy listening to REAL music! 104 koogles 12/01/2000 09:24AM
RE: Sorry, I've been too busy listening to REAL mu 114 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 11:15AM
RE: Sorry, I've been too busy listening to REAL mu 121 koogles 12/01/2000 12:49PM
Eminem vs. the Backstreet Boys! 115Captain Chaos12/02/2000 06:15AM
RE: Eminem vs. the Backstreet Boys! 147 koogles 12/02/2000 10:07AM
RE: Eminem vs. the Backstreet Boys! 96Captain Chaos12/05/2000 12:52AM
Enough already! 98 koogles 12/05/2000 01:52AM
Not Eminem but MTM 165 koogles 12/03/2000 04:25AM
RE: Sorry, I've been too busy listening to REAL mu 120 Mike 12/01/2000 01:52PM
RE: If you don't stand for something... 110 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 09:19AM
Is this Kurt Jackson? 101 koogles 12/01/2000 09:35AM
RE: nope 106 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 11:14AM
RE: Is this Kurt Jackson? 106Robert12/02/2000 12:07AM
RE: If you don't stand for something... 106 Jennifer T 12/01/2000 03:29PM
RE: If you don't stand for something... 90 koogles 12/02/2000 01:03AM
Andrew Pls Remove this Idiot Koogles. 120 RAMMY 12/02/2000 01:52AM
RE: Andrew Pls Remove this Idiot Koogles. 110 Jennifer T 12/02/2000 03:57AM
RE: Andrew Pls Remove this Idiot Koogles. 120 koogles 12/02/2000 08:04AM
Andrew- we have a nazi (RAMMY) on this board 135 koogles 12/02/2000 07:59AM
Got Ya! 99 RAMMY 12/02/2000 08:20AM
There you go again... you don't learn do you? 128 koogles 12/02/2000 09:40AM
Silly Boy ... 117 RAMMY 12/02/2000 07:38PM
You're a fascist plain and simple, RAMMY 139 koogles 12/03/2000 12:14AM
RE: You're a fascist plain and simple, RAMMY 131 RAMMY 12/03/2000 02:08AM
Yeah, your name-calling makes you a MAN alright! 128 koogles 12/03/2000 04:00AM
By the way... 98 koogles 12/03/2000 04:09AM
Theres a Good Boy np 109 RAMMY 12/03/2000 04:29AM
you 3 just f*ck off 118 Chris 12/04/2000 02:34AM
Cease-fire 118 koogles 12/04/2000 09:51AM
RE: Here's my two cents.. spend it as you may 116Ryan12/01/2000 02:20AM
Music is Life 96 Jordan in Jersey 12/02/2000 01:03AM
RE: Music is Life 119 koogles 12/02/2000 01:12AM
RE: Music is Life 143 sfk kurt 12/02/2000 04:40AM
RE: Music is Life 126 sfk kurt 12/02/2000 04:39AM
RE: Music is Life 110 Jordan in Jersey 12/02/2000 06:51AM
RE: Music is Life 101 Lil Al 12/02/2000 08:53AM
RE: Music is Life 144 sfk kurt 12/02/2000 10:41AM
RE: Music is Life 127 Lil Al 12/03/2000 07:34AM
RE: Music is Life 117 sfk kurt 12/03/2000 08:28AM
RE: Music is Life 121 Lil Al 12/03/2000 09:19AM
RE: Music is Life 117 sfk kurt 12/03/2000 10:42AM
RE: Music is Life 124 Mike 12/02/2000 10:35AM
RE: NO COMPROMISE ON "REAL MELODIC ROCK" 110 sfk kurt 12/01/2000 01:17AM
It just goes to show...... 125 Geoff 12/01/2000 09:26AM
RE:Life without Music would be a mistake 128 Lil Al 12/01/2000 09:39AM
Koogles is a comedy star 122 Paul stephenson 12/02/2000 02:15AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.