"Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line?
Posted by: nivjourney ()
Date: December 18, 2012 11:14AM

Just thinking about the Chaz West and Asia posts from before?
Where do fans draw the line on a band no longer being acceptable as the same band?
Giant - replace Dann Huff and there's braying for blood, "how could Frontiers do this, it's not Giant, i'll never buy another album... blah blah blah"
Hardline - the singer records a project entirely written and produced by a hired backing team of Italian guys who also all write and play on many other albums together not under the name "Hardline", and they are suitable headliners for Firefests 10th Anniversary?
Foreigner, Journey, AC/DC, Styx have all replaced the unreplaceable and been largely embraced, and had great success and longevity.
Yet the same fans who embrace these guys would turn their noses up at bands like Giant, John Payne's Asia (I know it's ridiculous that he introduces songs he, nor any other band member, had anything to do with as "a song from our album", but that's the nature of performing at state fairs and summer festivals where no-one really knows who the fuck any of you are... at the end of the day he and Guthrie had longer tenures in Asia than John Wetton or Steve Howe ever did), Sweet, Vixen, and so many others...
What's the difference?
I'm not shit-stirring, i'm genuinely curious. I tend to like a band no matter who's in it, if the music is good or at least to my liking.
If Firefest had been headlined by the Dann-less Giant and Over The Rainbow, this noticeboard would have been full of detractors and nay-sayers... but Hardline and Legends feat Joe Lynn Turner, Eric Martin & Fergie Frederiksen playing the hits of Rainbow, Mr. Big and Toto, are somehow more acceptable... why is that?
Intrigued...
Niv

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
"Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line?423 nivjourney 12/18/2012 11:14AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 285 Troy 12/18/2012 01:21PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 250 Captain Can Man 12/18/2012 03:19PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 184 nivjourney 12/18/2012 10:19PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 141 Troy 12/19/2012 02:13AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 125 Captain Can Man 12/19/2012 02:19AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 116 Troy 12/19/2012 03:32AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 121 Captain Can Man 12/19/2012 03:37AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 124 nivjourney 12/19/2012 08:24AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 99 Troy 12/19/2012 05:31PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 87 nivjourney 12/19/2012 10:50PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 155 MetroGnome 12/18/2012 09:29PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 189 MCFCTrick 12/18/2012 06:46PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 193 GuitarheroAndy 12/18/2012 07:12PM
Legends Voies Of Rock 262 Tommy-Denander 12/18/2012 07:52PM
Re: Legends Voices Of Rock 188 nivjourney 12/18/2012 10:24PM
Re: Legends Voies Of Rock 102 RAB 12/19/2012 07:03PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 198 Laurent 12/18/2012 09:00PM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 82 Big Al 12/20/2012 12:11AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 61 Tony Bainbridge 12/20/2012 05:54AM
Re: "Tribute Band" - Where do people draw the line? 64 nivjourney 12/20/2012 10:01AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.