Not crazy talk if you view Magnum as good solid rock and nothing more. I don't get the fuss over Magnum - I don't dislike them but The Tower is about the only thing Catley's on that gets regular play. I have a couple of his other solo albums but never really got around to playing them properly.

I didn't grow up with Magnum (worked my way back to them in my 30's based on Andrew's love of them) but they just don't click with me.