Well...to compare any two things is always a debatable concept. But as singers...let's just say I can admire JH's voice much more than Axel's. Even if I didn't prefer what The Darkness is about,I still have to say he (Hawkins) has the better voice,quality-wise. I like a few GnR tunes despite Rose's whine. But I like/can listen to most of what The Darkness has recorded. It's not 'rubbish', OR 'dreadful' by a long shot. You can't deny the guitar stylings--very solid AND melodic playing for their songs. jUst not for everyone. But then..what is? T