RE: Journey should sue the Sign
Posted by: Terry ()
Date: November 30, 2000 08:25AM

I never usually get involved in these types of discussions,but after hearing about the similarities between "Desperate Heart" and "Any....." for the 13 billionth time,I 've had it. So,as I was sitting here burning Paul a CD of the original master of "Back In America" from Network ( a friend of mine told me he had been looking for one), I decided to respond from my perspective.

1. I agree,it's my least favorite song along with "Nothin But....". The verse IS derivative.But ,when writing it,Mark said he had written a similar verse in an old Touch song that pre-dated Journey's song.So,whatever........Beethoven took all the good notes anyway.No intent was ever there,I think all this discussion of it is hilarious,anyway.

2. Journey should DEFINITELY sue us for our aggregious plagarism!! They,after all,could use the money, being destitute, and we are all obviosly CLEANING UP from all the bazillions of dollars in royalties we're making off the song.

Terry Brock

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Journey should sue the Sign 102 paul stephenson 11/28/2000 10:38PM
RE: Journey should sue the Sign 57beetle11/28/2000 11:15PM
Hugo 61 Susumu 11/28/2000 11:35PM
Belinda Carlisle and Bon Jovi 138Captain Chaos11/29/2000 12:16AM
Similarity does not equal plagarism 101 koogles 11/29/2000 01:02AM
Marvelous 3 and The Byrds 78 x factor 11/29/2000 11:40PM
RE: Marvelous 3 and The Byrds 227 koogles 11/30/2000 09:41AM
RE: Journey should sue the Sign 60 Kimmo 11/30/2000 02:45AM
RE: Journey should sue the Sign 66 Paul stephenson 12/02/2000 02:32AM
RE: Journey should sue the Sign 63Terry12/04/2000 06:49AM
Celine dion and Bon Jovi 80 alex siedler 11/29/2000 12:56AM
RE: Journey should sue the Sign61Terry11/30/2000 08:25AM
RE: Journey should sue the Sign 68Captain Chaos12/01/2000 06:15AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.