musings on the rating system...
Posted by: Kevin ()
Date: October 05, 2012 01:50PM

rocknut Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> As I said last night, Shawn, I was commenting
> solely on the stats. That figure is an 'average'
> though, so to get an average of over 80% the
> marking is high.


basically a copy of what I said below... Here's a simple fix. Deduct about 10% from what's marked and you are a) close to Andrew's old rating system before the numbers started increasing.....and b) leaving an edge at the top for the truly transcending release if and when.

then you end up with something like this....
below 70%....needs work in multiple areas.
70%.....good points and some areas for improvement (aka average)
70-80%....getting better. "Fillers" decrease. Pretty good overall.
80-85%....good songs throughout. Maybe not classics, but solid songs from beginning to end. No fillers. Nothing to be ashamed of here. This is a solid recommendation.
85-95%....very good songs. Potentially some classics. Likely to have multiple entries in the band's "best of" list. Expect rave reviews for a cd like this.
95%+....classic. Genre transcending release.

As you might notice, it gets more difficult the closer you get to that perfect score. Every song becomes more important to the whole.

As far as production goes, that rating can deduct from a score, but should NEVER add to it. The best production will never help a mediocre song, but a bad production can hurt a good song.

just my thoughts on the matter...
Kevin

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 773 Scott 10/04/2012 11:05PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 555 Figge 10/04/2012 11:07PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 529 Terry K. 10/04/2012 11:11PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 510 Pelata 10/04/2012 11:20PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 486 rocknut 10/04/2012 11:24PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 421 Terry K. 10/04/2012 11:29PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 455 Pelata 10/04/2012 11:55PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 419 rocknut 10/05/2012 12:50AM
musings on the rating system...386 Kevin 10/05/2012 01:50PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 381 Andrew 10/05/2012 01:58PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 277 Michael Eaton 10/05/2012 07:33PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 280 rocknut 10/05/2012 07:53PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 284 Michael Eaton 10/05/2012 08:09PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 255 Andrew 10/05/2012 08:19PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 252 rocknut 10/05/2012 08:50PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 255 Andrew 10/05/2012 09:32PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 260 rocknut 10/05/2012 09:44PM
Re: musings on the rating system... 219 Coco 10/06/2012 12:35AM
Re: musings on the rating system... 235 rocknut 10/06/2012 12:42AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 435 Coco 10/05/2012 02:13AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 607 Andrew 10/04/2012 11:36PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 484 soldierofthenight 10/05/2012 12:19AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 555 SEAN1 10/05/2012 12:37AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 469 rocknut 10/05/2012 12:52AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 313 Kevin 10/05/2012 01:59PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 347 Andrew 10/05/2012 02:43PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 328 LARocks 10/05/2012 03:39PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 312 Andrew 10/05/2012 03:46PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 307 rocknut 10/05/2012 04:24PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 327 Andrew 10/05/2012 04:27PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 251 rocknut 10/05/2012 05:29PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 276 Andrew 10/05/2012 05:50PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 243 Coco 10/05/2012 08:10PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 264 Andrew 10/05/2012 08:20PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 252 rocknut 10/05/2012 08:52PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 254 LARocks 10/05/2012 09:23PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 234 rocknut 10/05/2012 09:46PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 225 Coco 10/05/2012 09:49PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 213 rocknut 10/05/2012 09:52PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 230 Coco 10/05/2012 09:48PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 226 rocknut 10/05/2012 09:51PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 218 Coco 10/05/2012 09:55PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 246 rocknut 10/05/2012 09:58PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 239 Coco 10/05/2012 10:05PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 228 rocknut 10/05/2012 10:13PM
Here you go..... 250 rocknut 10/05/2012 10:16PM
Re: Here you go..... 226 Scott 10/05/2012 10:29PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 243 Coco 10/05/2012 10:27PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 221 rocknut 10/05/2012 10:32PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 234 Terry K. 10/05/2012 11:35PM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 237 rocknut 10/06/2012 12:18AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 223 Terry K. 10/06/2012 12:24AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 225 rocknut 10/06/2012 12:39AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 214 SEAN1 10/06/2012 02:01AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 201 rocknut 10/06/2012 02:07AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 265 Coco 10/06/2012 12:31AM
Re: What happened to the JIMI JAMISON thread? 241 rocknut 10/06/2012 12:37AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.