When is a re-issue not a re-issue?
Posted by: koogles ()
Date: November 26, 2000 02:37AM

My friend and I have been debating on and off this year about the legitimacy of CD re-issues. He will contest that certain releases (notably on the Axepertise and Metal Mayhem labels) are not proper re-issues but rather professional-quality bootlegs. Where does one draw the line between bootleg and re-issue? I, for one, am quite satisfied with the sound quality of my Waysted "Save Your Prayers" and Axe "Offering" CDs both on the Axepertise label. My friend has negated these as "cheesy bootlegs". I always believed that if a CD was digitally transferred from the original masters, the artwork had remained faithful to the original, the packaging was professional and the copyright royalties were paid out to the appropriate parties, then THAT is what constituted a legitimate re-issue. For most consumers, it is hard to know the goings-on with respect to the business end of things and whether or not copyright laws have been observed. That leaves us with the CD itself. However, with technology being so advanced these days, it is easy to manufacture a product that walks and talks like the real thing, but is, in fact, an imitation. My friend, for instance, insists that my copy of Fate's "A Matter of Attitude" is, to quote Donnie Brasco, a "fugazi" but only the well-trained eye would ever be able to make that distinction. Everything about this CD screams "original pressing" except apparently the inner ring pattern is somewhat irregular or something.
I guess the real issue here is: how high does the quality of a bootleg have to be before it is accepted as a "legitimate" re-issue? Does fake stop being fake when it possesses the ability to fool a majority? Any thoughts...

koogles

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
When is a re-issue not a re-issue?192 koogles 11/26/2000 02:37AM
RE: When is a re-issue not a re-issue? 103John Q11/26/2000 08:08PM
RE: When is a re-issue not a re-issue? 120 Steve 11/27/2000 12:02AM
Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 134 koogles 11/27/2000 09:54AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 181 Billy D'Allyn 11/27/2000 06:53PM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 119 koogles 11/28/2000 12:08AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 101 Steve 11/28/2000 01:05AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 133John Q11/28/2000 05:43AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 137 Billy D'Allyn 11/28/2000 10:39AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 128John Q11/28/2000 11:31AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 115 Billy D'Allyn 11/29/2000 12:13PM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 147 Billy D'Allyn 11/28/2000 02:16AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 118 koogles 11/28/2000 09:23AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 124 Steve 11/28/2000 09:53AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 112 ryan 11/28/2000 10:36AM
Steve- you make me laugh. 127 koogles 11/28/2000 11:59AM
RE: Steve- you make me laugh. 121 Steve 11/28/2000 12:36PM
RE: Steve- you make me laugh. 112 koogles 11/28/2000 12:53PM
RE: Steve- you make me laugh. 109 Steve 11/28/2000 02:57PM
RE: Steve- you make me laugh. 107 koogles 11/28/2000 11:46PM
Another pointer of concern - Production quality 132 Nicky 11/29/2000 06:27AM
RE: Metal Mayhem re-issues questionable? 130 Billy D'Allyn 11/28/2000 10:53AM
Steve and Billy- where's your class? 158 koogles 11/28/2000 11:43AM
RE: Metal Mayhem 1 Mensa members 0 118 Lil Al 11/28/2000 03:38PM
If it was just about the music... 115 koogles 11/29/2000 12:32AM
RE: OK, NOW I HAVE TO SAYTHING! 136 JUDGE JUDY 11/29/2000 12:58AM
Take a recess, Judge Judy. 102 koogles 11/29/2000 01:14AM
RE: Take a recess, Judge Judy. 122 JUDGE JUDY 11/29/2000 03:32AM
RE: Take a recess, Judge Judy. 112 koogles 11/29/2000 04:50AM
RE: Take a recess, Judge Judy. 118 Steve 11/29/2000 04:59AM
RE: Take a recess, Judge Judy. 104 Steve 11/29/2000 05:04AM
Steve, you STILL make me laugh. 92 koogles 11/29/2000 05:40AM
Koogles GET's KO'd!! 107 Jennifer T 11/29/2000 07:16AM
I'm still standing.. 129 koogles 11/29/2000 12:27PM
RE: Koogles GET's KO'd!! 98 Billy D'Allyn 12/01/2000 10:38AM
Okay, Billy, here's something worth fighting for! 138 koogles 12/01/2000 12:42PM
RE: Okay, Billy, here's something worth fighting f 119 Jennifer T 12/01/2000 03:55PM
RE: Okay, Billy, here's something worth fighting f 94 koogles 12/02/2000 12:58AM
RE: Take a recess, Judge Judy. 129 JUDGE JUDY 11/29/2000 07:59AM
Judge Judy, when will you GET IT? 134 koogles 11/29/2000 12:51PM
RE: Judge Judy, when will you GET IT? 116 JUDGE JUDY 11/29/2000 02:56PM
RE: Judge Judy, when will you GET IT? 117 koogles 11/30/2000 01:13AM
RE: Judge Judy, when will you GET IT? 114 JUDGE JUDY 11/30/2000 05:56AM
RE: Judge Judy, when will you GET IT? 121 JUDGE JUDY 11/30/2000 05:58AM
Give it up 111 koogles 11/30/2000 08:37AM
RE: Koogles/PJ, get a reality check! 134 Billy D'Allyn 11/29/2000 11:35AM
The childish rebuttals keep on comin'... 105 koogles 11/29/2000 12:14PM
RE: The childish rebuttals keep on comin'... 117 JUDGE JUDY 11/29/2000 03:01PM
RE: The childish rebuttals keep on comin'... 125 koogles 11/30/2000 01:42AM
Koogles swings from his family tree! 91 Billy D'Allyn 12/01/2000 10:49AM
You have successfully advertised your CD 96 koogles 12/01/2000 12:37PM
RE: You have successfully advertised your CD 128 Billy D'Allyn 12/02/2000 08:53AM
I will be buying one!! 113 Jennifer T 12/01/2000 03:58PM
RE: I will be buying one!! 105 Billy D'Allyn 12/02/2000 08:57AM
RE: Koogles/PJ, get a reality check! 108 Jennifer T 11/29/2000 11:00PM
Jennifer T- you are redundant and ridiculous 135 koogles 11/30/2000 01:29AM
ok this is funny but getting rediculous 116 fanof1982 11/30/2000 02:55AM
A word or two about collecting 137 koogles 11/30/2000 08:31AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.