RE: copyright infringement?
Posted by: Copious K9 ()
Date: October 22, 2000 11:43PM


The point I am trying to make is that the names of the files you see from others while logged onto Napster do not necessary reflect the content of those files.

If the evil minions of Sade's Napster Police noticed that you were listing one of her songs as d/l-able from your computer, they could prove that you had a file with her name in it, but they could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt the contents of said file unless

i) you d/l-ed the file from them (ie they ripped Sade's greatest hits and shared them on Napster looking to entrap)


ii) they d/l-ed the song from your computer and play it to verify content, which would take a great deal of time to prove each and every offender's "crime"

I doubt that they did either. I suspect that they did a search on "Sade" and made a list of all the users sharing files with her name in it.

Way back when, Metallica supposed had a list of 300,000+ Napster users who were sharing their files. The only feasible way for Metallica's evil minions to come up with that many names was to get them from search results, which proves nothing.

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote

SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Napster problem 371Bobo10/20/2000 10:25PM
RE: Napster problem 232Ferrari Sparklepants10/21/2000 12:32AM
RE: Napster problem 257Jack10/21/2000 01:03AM
RE: Napster problem 278Bobo10/21/2000 01:29AM
RE: Napster problem 215 Rather Large Canine 10/21/2000 01:41AM
RE: Napster problem 260 mike 10/21/2000 03:43AM
Now I Understand 232Ferrari Sparklepants10/21/2000 05:15AM
Legalese follows ... 230 Rather Large Canine 10/21/2000 05:33AM
RE: Legalese follows ... 571 Stimpy 10/21/2000 06:31AM
stimpy mp3's have nothing to do with it 212 mike 10/21/2000 06:34AM
RE: stimpy mp3's have nothing to do with it 207 Stimpy 10/21/2000 06:38AM
sorry stimpy 259 mike 10/21/2000 06:45AM
RE: sorry stimpy 294 Stimpy 10/21/2000 07:00AM
copyright infringement? 208 Big Dog 10/21/2000 12:30PM
RE: copyright infringement? 177 mike 10/21/2000 05:02PM
RE: copyright infringement?198 Copious K9 10/22/2000 11:43PM
RE: Legalese follows ... 258 mike 10/21/2000 06:32AM
RE: Napster problem 233 Jeremy 10/21/2000 11:21AM

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.