RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1
Posted by: Kevin ()
Date: October 18, 2000 11:11AM

Kilzer wrote:
-------------------------------
I think the reason Jimi only sang a couple of Dave songs live is because all of their hits with the exception of a couple songs were done with Jimi. Why would he sing album cuts from Dave's era that most of the fans won't even know?

DK


same reason that they played about 4 songs off Too Hot To Sleep this year---which nobody knows either since that cd flopped saleswise. Up thru '99 when Bickler was still in the band, they were playing primarily Dave material with the JJ hits thrown in there--including some REALLY rare stuff like "Nothing Can Shake Me (From Your Love)" which was on the 1st cd, but a staple of the live shows from about '97 on. Now, it's totally the opposite with a lot of JJ rare stuff that nobody knows either....so my take on it is that if they are going to play songs nobody knows anyways, might as well cover both eras of the band and pick the best songs. Of course, to be honest, there is probably some stuff about egos floating around like in Van Halen where Sammy won't sing DLR's songs and visa versa that JJ doesn't like to sing Dave Bickler's songs.

Actually, the really weird part about it is on the Vital Signs tour, which was JJ's first tour with the band, the few Dave songs they did were sometimes REALLY strange like "I'm Not That Man Anymore" which...a) isn't really a killer live song....and b) is a deep album cut if there ever was one--why do that when there were a lot of songs that were really suited to the live environment??? Who knows--maybe part of it also concerns the fact that Dave could sing higher than JJ did when he wanted to and Jamison can't hit the notes these days. JJ was definitely not hitting the high notes--and seemed to be straining a bit on the higher parts--when he covered "Ever Since the World Began" back in 95--and that was when his voice was in top shape!

Kevin

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 141 Chris 10/18/2000 07:51AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 104 Brian Mc 10/18/2000 08:01AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 153 Kevin 10/18/2000 09:22AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 99 Kilzer 10/18/2000 10:09AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1105 Kevin 10/18/2000 11:11AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 113 Kilzer 10/18/2000 11:27AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 94 Kevin 10/18/2000 12:24PM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 102 Susumu 10/18/2000 08:15PM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 114 Kevin 10/18/2000 10:15PM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 102Captain Chaos10/18/2000 11:22PM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 110 Kevin 10/19/2000 03:30AM
RE: Jamison vs Bickler, round 1 110Captain Chaos10/19/2000 05:14AM
Survivor vs. Starship 99 Kevin 10/19/2000 06:05AM
RE: Survivor vs. Starship 107Captain Chaos10/19/2000 09:59PM
RE: Speaking Of ...Starship 94 Susumu 10/19/2000 10:21PM
RE: Speaking Of ...Starship 96 Mike 10/19/2000 11:58PM
RE: Speaking Of ...Starship 80 sfk kurt 10/20/2000 04:38AM
RE: Speaking Of ...Starship 106 Kevin 10/20/2000 01:10AM
RE: Speaking Of ...Starship 116hengank10/23/2000 07:34AM
RE: Speaking Of ...Starship 113 Susumu 10/23/2000 09:37PM
RE: Survivor vs. Starship 98 sfk kurt 10/20/2000 04:39AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.