RE: Just for interest's sake...
Posted by: Don ()
Date: September 03, 2000 01:48AM

...(and not that I'm trying to drag this out or anything, it's just that this goes to show what I've been raving about regarding personal taste and all) I'll comment on the "filler" tracks you listed:

'You Say Yes' - The closest thing to filler that you've mentioned (IMO). Still, if I had a choice of owning the "Point of Entry" album with or without this track, I'd rather have it.

'Parential Guidance' - Lyrics are astoundingly corny and contrived, but it's still a d@mn catchy song and there's no way I'd want it left off of "Turbo." I can fully understand and appreciate why so many Priest fans hated this album, and yet, for me it just served to prove that if JP wanted to do the more commercial kind of metal that was so huge in those days, they could not only compete with the Ratts and Crues, but blow them away. Now, that's a bit of an over-simplification, but I still think that in the end, this was meant to be a commercial metal album, and it wound up succeeding in this regard. It was a collection of 8 finely crafted, potentially huge radio/video "hits" ("Hot For Love" just didn't stack up - it was "filler" :-) ). Tracks like "Reckless" "Out in the Cold," "Locked In," and "Wild Nights..." were amazingly hook-laden and simply oozed airplay potential. Trouble is, that's not what most Priest fans wanted or expected from JP. Still, in my mind, that doesn't make it a bad album. (Same with Harem Scarem's "Rubber" - if that album had been made by the Collective Soul, a lot of people who hated it might have been more willing to give it a chance. But many HS fans are gonna be disappointed with anything that doesn't sound like "Mood Swings.") My advice to those people is to just listen to it, enjoy it, and tell themselves it was Dokken, or Ratt, or whatever.

the horribly bad 'Johnny B. Goode' - I agree here, but then again, I've already established that I am not at all a fan of either the "Ram It Down" or "Painkiller" albums. Interestingly, I've heard that "Ram it Down" was basically made up of the leftover tracks from the "Turbo" sessions. I remember reading that they had recorded LOTS of tracks and considered making a double album. Instead, apparently, they grouped the radio friendly ones for "Turbo," and held back the heavier/less commercial ones for "RiD." I don't know how much truth there is to this story, but it's what I've read.

'Don't Go' - Admittedly, this is not one of my fave tracks either. See comments re. "You Say Yes."

'Fever' - I LOVE this track!!! For me, every song on "Screaming For Vengeance" is absolutely vital.

'Some Heads Are Gonna Roll' - This is one of my fave tracks from "Defenders." For me, the album definitely wouldn't be as good without it.

In the end, all I'm trying to do is reinforce my point (and not just to you, John), that taste in music is a totally personal thing. When one person listens to a track from an album (or an entire album) and feels nothing, he/she needs to realize that someone else out there is probably loving that material in a huge way. So which person is right? I dunno, but that raises the question, "Who's qualified to judge?" And how do you judge an artform like music? IMO, it can't be done. Everyone listens for a slightly different reason. That's why tastes differ. This has been my sermon for the day, LOL!!

Take care, and thanks again for your input, John.
Don




SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Halford-Resurrection 138 mike 09/01/2000 02:12AM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 111Surfpunk09/01/2000 05:32AM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 96John Q09/01/2000 05:44AM
RE: John Q - regarding Iron Maiden 91 Don 09/01/2000 06:42AM
Sorry to butt in... 92 Benno 09/01/2000 09:36AM
RE: Sorry to butt in...Maiden fan -Don 114 KAOS FAN 09/01/2000 11:24AM
RE: Thanks Benno & KAOS... 94 Don 09/01/2000 12:55PM
RE: regarding Iron Maiden 95John Q09/01/2000 11:26AM
RE: regarding Iron Maiden 96 Dave 09/01/2000 02:24PM
RE: Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, etc. 99 Don 09/01/2000 02:57PM
RE: Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, etc. 93John Q09/02/2000 06:04PM
RE: Just for interest's sake...83 Don 09/03/2000 01:48AM
RE: regarding Iron Maiden 94Surfpunk09/02/2000 11:24AM
RE: regarding Iron Maiden 92John Q09/02/2000 05:43PM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 91 EchoMan 09/01/2000 07:39PM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 94 Davy(N.I.) 09/02/2000 06:10AM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 97 Rob 09/08/2000 04:30AM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 87 Thomas 09/03/2000 03:54AM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 112John Q09/03/2000 08:10AM
RE: Halford-Resurrection 93 Thomas 09/03/2000 11:16AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.