RE: New "Journey" Album -- Let's Get Thi
Posted by: Coorsman ()
Date: September 01, 2000 06:40AM

Oh, I've just GOT to reply to this message.

If the only way you can "prove" your point is by mentioning Marillion, Styx, and Wildest Dreams you need to try a little harder. That's really reaching there, pal.

Look, as was said in an earlier post --- FIRST doesn't equal BEST.

In this case the argument is NOT that "Steve Perry" was first. Everyone knows Perry wasn't there from the beginning. The OPINION expressed by myself and a precious few others on this board is that Perry, during his time with Journey, BECAME such an integral part of the band's identity that it seems ludicrous to expect that the band will still be Journey without him.

sfk kurt wrote:

"Have you forgotten that Perry was not an original member of the band? Technically, maybe they weren't Journey without Robert Fleichman. "

Hey, pal... To me, Journey never really was JOURNEY before Perry came onboard. It's the same way that Rush before Neil Peart isn't really Rush. Peart came into the band, began writing 99.95% of all the songs they've done in the past 25 years or so and brought his identifiable and unique drumwork to the band's music. So that now, if Peart were to leave the band and Rush decided to continue without him it might be something but it wouldn't be RUSH.

Sometimes a member of a band becomes truly "irreplaceable." Hey, I'd feel the same way if Perry was trying to do Journey without Neal Schon. For me, those two are the true heart of Journey. One without the other is really nothing more than a glorified solo project. Perry's solo albums aren't Journey. Bad English wasn't Journey. And this new thing calling itself "Journey" isn't Journey. I'm finished trying to tell you guys you aren't gonna like it. Apparently a lot of you DO like it. Fine. All I'm asking is that you at least concede the point that it's not the Journey we could have had if they'd waited for Perry to recover. Give me that at least.



SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
New "Journey" Album 265 MACK 08/30/2000 04:33AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 173 Kevin 08/30/2000 04:55AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 164 sfk kurt 08/30/2000 06:06AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 143Robert08/30/2000 06:48AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 152 Shannon 08/30/2000 12:23PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 165 sfk kurt 08/30/2000 11:54PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 161 Brian 08/31/2000 06:00AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 136 Coorsman 08/30/2000 12:43PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 176c dog08/30/2000 02:26PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 127 Coorsman 08/30/2000 07:42PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 186 Kevin 08/31/2000 02:29AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 143 Eric 08/31/2000 11:23AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 137 Coorsman 08/31/2000 11:41AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 137 Kevin 08/31/2000 01:07PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 113 sfk kurt 08/31/2000 08:26PM
RE: New "Journey" Album -- Let's Get Thi 176 Brian 09/01/2000 08:41AM
Brian....check your e-mail (np) 191 Kevin 09/01/2000 09:32AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 168 sfk kurt 08/30/2000 11:58PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 153 sfk kurt 08/30/2000 11:55PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 136 don 08/30/2000 10:19AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 180 MACK 08/30/2000 12:25PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 170SP08/31/2000 04:39AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 137 bRIAN 08/30/2000 11:07AM
RE: New "Journey" Album - Ian Gillan etc 174 KAOS FAN 08/30/2000 12:46PM
RE: New "Journey" Album - Ian Gillan etc 140 Coorsman 08/30/2000 12:49PM
RE: New "Journey" Album - Ian Gillan etc 144 joemo5 08/30/2000 01:42PM
RE: New "Journey" Album - Ian Gillan etc 168 Aaron 08/30/2000 07:54PM
RE: New "Journey" Album - Ian Gillan etc 167 ed 08/31/2000 01:50AM
Journey's Arrival cd 175 ed 09/01/2000 12:37PM
RE: Journey's Arrival cd 135 sfk kurt 09/02/2000 07:11AM
RE: New "Journey" Album - Ian Gillan etc 135 Kevin 08/31/2000 02:33AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 179 Gabe 08/31/2000 10:52AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 130 corey 08/31/2000 11:07AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 143 Kevin 08/31/2000 01:10PM
RE: New "Journey" Album 186 Carl C. 09/01/2000 03:14AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 112Travis09/01/2000 03:25AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 123 Kevin 09/01/2000 03:39AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 164 Carl 09/01/2000 03:26AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 146SP09/02/2000 11:34AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 163 sfk kurt 09/01/2000 05:30AM
RE: New "Journey" Album -- Let's Get Thi163 Coorsman 09/01/2000 06:40AM
They cut off my subject line! 124 Coorsman 09/01/2000 06:42AM
RE: New "Journey" Album -- Let's Get Thi 128 Kevin 09/01/2000 07:12AM
RE: New "Journey" Album -- Let's Get Thi 156 sfk kurt 09/01/2000 09:01AM
RE: New "Journey": It's the singer not t 141 Lil Al 09/03/2000 04:53AM
RE: New "Journey": It's the singer not t 175 sfk kurt 09/03/2000 05:41AM
RE: New "Journey": It's the singer not t 121 eric 09/03/2000 07:29AM
RE: New "Journey": It's the singer not t 153 Lil Al 09/05/2000 02:07AM
RE: New "Journey": It's the singer not t 195 Lil Al 09/05/2000 02:23AM
RE: New "Journey" Album -- Let's Get Thi 175 Eric 09/01/2000 10:33AM
RE: New "Journey" Album 167 Eric 09/01/2000 10:23AM
RE: Borderning on Spinal Tap!!! 197 Lil Al 09/05/2000 02:45AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.