Comparing HS and ER is very superficial.
Posted by: Big Bow Wow ()
Date: September 01, 2000 12:29PM

The two bands' music (songs without the vocals) is completely different, albeit the same MHR genre. The two lead guitarists in no way sound the same.

The vocals are similar, but the lyrics comparatively are not similar at all.

So what it really all boils down to is that ER and HS have similar vocals. ER were formed from a band called Pain, which was more of alternative band. I own one Pain CD, which has the same vocalist as ER, and the vocalist sounds the same in both bands. In ER, the vocal arrangements have changed to match the MHR genre. Now the fact that both ER and HS vocalist sound the same is more of coincidence than a devious plot to be as unoriginal as possible so as to win over fans of the older HS CDs.

I am surprised that since the topic originality was brought up that no one has mentioned that the much beloved two first HS CDs are not that original in the MHR genre. Harry Hess admits as much.

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 80 KAOS FAN 08/29/2000 11:58PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! bollox 53Pete08/30/2000 03:57AM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 64 sfk kurt 08/30/2000 10:49AM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 60 Vince Viani 08/30/2000 11:23AM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 56 Carl 08/30/2000 12:32PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 52 Kevin 08/30/2000 01:05PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 48 Carl 08/30/2000 02:02PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 55 Kevin 08/30/2000 02:41PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 59 Vince Viani 08/31/2000 05:10PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 53 sfk kurt 08/31/2000 05:18PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 48 Carl 08/31/2000 06:37PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 63 Carl 08/31/2000 06:35PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 64 Richard 08/31/2000 09:18PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 54emontes@airtel.es08/30/2000 06:25PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 50 Eva 08/30/2000 06:32PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 52 Eva 08/30/2000 06:28PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 80 sfk kurt 08/30/2000 02:31PM
Imitators can never be better than the original 64joe08/30/2000 03:14PM
RE: Imitators can never be better than the origina 61 KAOS FAN 08/30/2000 11:09PM
RE: Imitators can never be better than the origina 59 Vince Viani 08/31/2000 05:21PM
RE: Imitators can never be better than the origina 58 sfk kurt 08/31/2000 09:14PM
RE: Imitators can never be better than the origina 63 Kevin 09/01/2000 12:29AM
RE: Imitators can never be better than the origina 57 sfk kurt 09/01/2000 07:29AM
RE: Imitators can never be better than the origina 57 Vince Viani 09/01/2000 11:05AM
Comparing HS and ER is very superficial.57 Big Bow Wow 09/01/2000 12:29PM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 56 Hutch 09/01/2000 12:30AM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 52 Kevin 09/01/2000 12:54AM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 59 sfk kurt 09/01/2000 07:30AM
RE: EMERALD RAIN -better than harem scarem! 53 Carl 09/01/2000 02:32PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.