re: STYX: Behind The Music
Posted by: ChrisD ()
Date: August 15, 2000 11:03PM

Clearly, you haven't seen the current line-up on tour....

As sad as it seems, Dennis Deyoung's time as a rocker has come and gone...while his theatrical vision and concepts helped prevent the group from being just another rock band in the 70s, by 1980 they were well on their way to completely removing the rock edge from Styx.
If anything, 1992's Edge of the Century was saved from being elevator music by Glen Burtnick's (and JY's) rockier contributions. Furthermore, the addition of Gowan is much needed -- he provides a solid songwriting foundation and ,unlike Deyoung in recent years, can really ROCK.
I look at it this way-- both Glen and Larry have successful solo careers and although being in Styx can't hurt financially, they could still be comfortable in those careers ("no-name" or not). Whereas everything from Return to Paradise onward had all the trappings of a nostalgia cash-in (70s line-up or no), I feel that now they have the potential to create some great AOR again with this talented "new" blood.

With this in mind, I think Styx are no less relevant than a reconstituted Journey, Van Halen or Pink Floyd. They certainly have more to offer than, say, the current line-ups of Yes, Asia or recent (pre-reunion) versions of Survivor...

Regards,

Chris D

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
STYX: Behind The Music 130 Marc 08/15/2000 08:52AM
STYX: Behind The Music 98John II08/15/2000 08:58AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 79John II08/15/2000 08:58AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 66 F.O.R.D. 08/15/2000 11:33AM
re: "Hired Nobodies?" 81 Geri 08/15/2000 09:33PM
re: STYX: Behind The Music84 ChrisD 08/15/2000 11:03PM
Your opinion is incorrect ;) 99 Rather Large Canine 08/16/2000 01:05AM
Re: F.O.R.D.--Ha! 78Robert08/16/2000 02:56AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 90 Eric 08/16/2000 09:04AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 87 Dave 08/16/2000 10:05AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 80 Bladesian 08/17/2000 02:44AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 85 Bladesian 08/17/2000 02:35AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 89 sfk kurt 08/17/2000 05:04AM
re: STYX: Behind The Music 76 Rocker Chic 08/17/2000 08:43AM
You tease!!! 92 Big Bow Wow 08/17/2000 10:03AM
RE: You tease!!! 83 Rocker Chic 08/18/2000 06:59AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.