RE: Journey
Posted by: sergio flavella ()
Date: August 07, 2000 10:55PM

I've just read all the nonsense in this thread about how Journey is such a great band and it has nothing to do with Steve Perry. Oh no, everyone rushed out to get the first few albums which are totally unlistenable. It needed Steve Perry and I think it's just ridiculous to say he gave it nothing more than the voice. He transformed a second-rate jazz act into the template for stadium rock-and that's also why Journey are universally reviled. Has anyone heard the song by Half Man Half Biscuit ( a British comedy punk band) it has the immortal line "I've only got six months to live , it could be worse I could be a member of Journey").
We all love them for the reasons most people hate them-great production, over-blown sentimental lyrics, every emotional punch delivered and cynically added just to make it hit the right spot. No wonder they are seen as the enemy by all things trendy and alternative. As for this debate about how wondeful Jonathan Cain or Neal Schon's solo ablums are ????? If you love that instrumental doddling so much what the hell do you see in Journey?
For the Love of Strange Medicine is quite glorious and who cares about the lyrics of 'You'd Better Wiat'-just hear the harmonies and that joyous swoop as Steve Perry tells us he is back.
What is with this speculation on who wrote what bit of what song? 'Send Her My Love' is the perfect ballad and I don't care if Jonathan did most of it or Steve just added a couple of lines, who cares?
Listen to the introduction of the bootleg version of 'Whose Cryin Now? and hear how they collaborated but that was probably just a couple of words or a line.
I saw Steve Augeri last summer and he was excellent but he just couldn't cope with 'Escape' and even 'Separate Ways' was beyond him on the 'Take care my love, miss you love' bit. Yes, he does a good job but he's not Steve Perry and the sooner you all stop making this claim that Journey is somehow as good without Steve Pery the better.
Finally how come Terry Brock never gets mentioned when the great AOR vocalists are talked of?

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Journey 240Nick08/04/2000 06:22AM
RE: Journey 194 Vince Viani 08/04/2000 10:48AM
RE: Journey 143 Eric 08/04/2000 01:52PM
RE: Journey/Van Halen 179Nick08/04/2000 04:45PM
RE: Journey/Van Halen 171 F.O.R.D. 08/05/2000 12:27AM
RE: Journey 139 Vince Viani 08/05/2000 02:00AM
RE: Journey 138 Brad 08/05/2000 03:13AM
Talk of Jonathan Cain 131Nick08/05/2000 05:36AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 185 Brad 08/05/2000 06:19AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 175 Kevin 08/05/2000 06:28AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 171 Brad 08/05/2000 06:55AM
well...... 207 Kevin 08/05/2000 01:28PM
RE: well...... 188 Brad 08/05/2000 01:45PM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 172 Vince Viani 08/05/2000 07:14AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 230Nick08/05/2000 04:02PM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 162 Brian Mc 08/06/2000 01:53AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 193 F.O.R.D. 08/06/2000 04:04AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 154Nicky08/06/2000 04:41AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 160 Eric 08/07/2000 03:11AM
RE: Talk of Jonathan Cain 176 Brian Mc 08/07/2000 01:22PM
RE: Journey 156 Vince Viani 08/05/2000 07:18AM
RE: Journey 137Gabe08/05/2000 11:32AM
RE: Journey 186 Brad 08/05/2000 01:39PM
RE: Journey 180 Eric 08/05/2000 01:42PM
RE: Journey 159 Brad 08/05/2000 01:49PM
RE: Journey 175 Kevin 08/05/2000 02:01PM
RE: Journey 147 Brad 08/05/2000 02:12PM
RE: Journey 152 Kevin 08/05/2000 03:02PM
RE: Journey 145Surfpunk08/06/2000 04:31AM
RE: Journey 144 F.O.R.D. 08/06/2000 04:34AM
RE: Journey/Def Leppard/Montrose 167Nicky08/06/2000 04:56AM
RE: Journey/Def Leppard/Montrose 154 F.O.R.D. 08/07/2000 02:14PM
RE: Journey 140 sergio 08/13/2000 07:45AM
RE: Journey 157 Kevin 08/06/2000 07:48AM
RE: Journey 201Nick08/06/2000 06:19PM
RE: Journey 144 Kevin 08/07/2000 08:25AM
RE: Journey - Tim Lewis the new Steve Perry!!! 183Nick08/07/2000 05:51PM
RE: Journey181 sergio flavella 08/07/2000 10:55PM
RE: Journey 146 Eric 08/08/2000 04:11AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.