speaking of Two Fires....
Posted by: Kevin ()
Date: July 18, 2000 06:12AM

maybe this is time to get a few points of view about the wide-ranging reaction to this release........but maybe before I get started, my points on Chalfant's career might be there as to why I feel the way I do...

707........hmm...average, at best. Maybe one or two good songs.
Steel Breeze.....way too poppy for my tastes, so I'll leave it at that.
The View...I'll reserve judgement until I hear the entire cd released, but of the infamous 7-song demo tape, this was the first time I was impressed with Chalfant. The original--and just slightly changed--version of "Remember" was on here.........why did it come out on 2F instead of The View cd?!?!?!?
The Storm - s/t.....interesting cd here for me. Definitely quite a few killer songs, but also a few fillers and more of the "average-to-kinda-good" songs. Good album? yea, I think so and not a bad debut either--especially on certain songs. Great/landmark cd? I don't think so, but on the other hand....
The Storm - Eye of the Storm.....one of the landmark, legendary AOR cds EVER for me and in my top 10 ever releases. Everything gelled on this cd and the promise of those few really exceptional moments of the debut was fulfilled. The Rolie/Chalfand were brilliant and songwise, I think the cd was better than any Journey cd as far as number of "killer songs" on the cd went. Under the right market with enough promotion, this should have established The Storm in the US, especially since they were kinda known after the tours and singles from the 1st cd.
Kevin Chalfant - Running with the Wind.....different, as expected, from The Storm, but I think it was pretty impressive for what it was. Couple of killer songs on this one also.

now.....to Two Fires.........couple of killers on here also, but I think there are quite a few of the "just ok" songs here also--so this goes similar to my review of the debut Storm cd, and more or less equal to Andrew's review. Also, I kinda liken it to one of Steve Perry's solo cds where you have a great voice, but the songs just don't fully reach those heights possible with the full band project.

so, for those that are saying this is SO good, what are you hearing there that I'm missing? I didn't expect another EOTS, but I'm hearing something almost like the feeling that the drive to create something really spectacular just wasn't there. What is everybody hearing here?

Kevin

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
2fires vs reynolds 220 peter 07/18/2000 12:18AM
RE: 2fires vs reynolds 115 Rammy 07/18/2000 12:50AM
Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 136Jack07/18/2000 01:23AM
Because that's what Messageboards are for ... 127 Rammy 07/18/2000 01:57AM
RE: Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 204Surfpunk07/18/2000 03:32AM
speaking of Two Fires....124 Kevin 07/18/2000 06:12AM
RE: speaking of Two Fires.... 119Chris07/18/2000 08:16AM
RE: speaking of Two Fires.... 115 Susumu 07/21/2000 08:10PM
Time for Mr.Chalfant to release a best of? 133 Nicky Baldrian 07/18/2000 09:10PM
RE: Time for Mr.Chalfant to release a best of? 118 Kevin 07/19/2000 02:37AM
RE: Time for Mr.Chalfant to release a best of? 137JT07/19/2000 03:25AM
RE: speaking of Two Fires.... 153 Nick Green 07/22/2000 10:18PM
Thanks! 115Jack07/19/2000 04:42AM
RE: Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 174 Kieran 07/19/2000 10:15AM
RE: Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 143 Nicky 07/19/2000 05:00PM
RE: Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 121 Kieran 07/20/2000 04:09AM
RE: Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 107Cybergimp07/23/2000 07:33PM
RE: Who the hell is Dave Reynolds, anyway?....... 121 Cybergimp 07/23/2000 07:35PM
2Fires. Sorry!!!!!!! 148 Rammy 07/19/2000 05:32PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.