I guess a few people liked the Gary Cherone era of Van Halen....but the majority of us were not impressed, and felt that he was not a fit into the band. I had an open mind when listening to VHIII, patiently listened to it over & over....it just never happened.

I am also a bit skeptical of the original lineup making a big comeback. I've seen group after group "re-form" with the original lineup, only to see 1 so-so cd released, maybe a tour, then see things fall apart. I just don't think Eddie has the fire or creativity that he once had, nor does the rest of the band. I am hopeful for a great cd......I guess we'll see soon enough.

And in the end, BIG EGOS will drive this band apart (see Dokken) & we'll see a new lead singer once again.