Herbie's pretty negative
Posted by: koogles ()
Date: August 26, 2001 07:38AM

Herbie seems to be taking a lion's share of the credit when it comes to Journey's success, but I don't recall him writing or performing any of the songs. I thought the interview was pretty negative, especially his belittlement of Jonathan Cain.

In fact, with so much pre-fabrication at work (from the album titles to the hand-picking of its members), Herbie plays into the hand of anyone who would argue that Journey are the paragons of "corporate rock".

I think Perry's attempt to wrest control away from Herbert is ironically manifested by the changing of "Freedom" to "Raised on Radio".

koogles

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Is Steve Perry Satan? 75John Q08/26/2001 05:23AM
no, herbie is! 63 sfk kurt 08/26/2001 05:51AM
Herbie's pretty negative56 koogles 08/26/2001 07:38AM
Re: Herbie's pretty negative 56 Eric Abrahamsen 08/26/2001 09:25AM
Very true! 56John Q08/26/2001 10:49AM
Re: Yes! 51 Eric Abrahamsen 08/26/2001 11:06AM
Re: Yes! 56 Mafia boy 08/27/2001 11:27AM
Re: Very true! 48 the ORIGINAL brent 08/26/2001 12:02PM
A bitter Herb? 70 koogles 08/27/2001 12:39AM
excellent point Koogs 62 sfk kurt 08/27/2001 03:06AM
Re: The Baby's did "stink" 54 Eric Abrahamsen 08/27/2001 03:47AM
The Babys were awesome! 55 sfk kurt 08/27/2001 04:22AM
Re: At one time... 45 Eric Abrahamsen 08/27/2001 04:43AM
everyone is entitled to a bad disc 55 sfk kurt 08/27/2001 05:35AM
Babys & Journey have one thing in common... 56 FORD 08/28/2001 12:08PM
Re: A bitter Herb? 57capt kaos08/27/2001 10:41PM
what Herbie thinks of Steve Augeri ... 53 Big Doggie 08/28/2001 03:31AM
Re: Steve Perry 74 Eric Abrahamsen 08/26/2001 05:53AM
Re: Steve Perry 64 honestabe30 08/26/2001 09:16AM
Any singer as good as Perry... 60 koogles 08/27/2001 12:50AM
Re: Is Steve Perry Satan? 62 croman 08/26/2001 01:49PM
Re: Is Steve Perry Satan? NOPE! 54 george 08/27/2001 05:25PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.