Sorry ..
Posted by: Misterpomp ()
Date: August 20, 2001 03:30AM

but I'd agree with Eric. MC and OM were two albums I really really loved when they came out (in fact Marillion were my favourite band at that time by a long chalk). Now OM sounds no more than a better than average mid 80s hard rock / metal album while I couldn't / wouldn't listen to MC if you paid me. Oh you are going to pay me.. then I'll change my mind :-). I do think Misplaced Childhood will eventually be more famous as the album that gave us a new girl's name than as an ouevre, OM will be better regarded but not as a classic. Just one opinion.

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
best album of all-time 55 croman 08/19/2001 02:04PM
Overrated!!!!!!! 41Kris08/19/2001 03:28PM
Re: Overrated!!!!!!! 45 croman 08/19/2001 03:32PM
Re: Overrated!!!!!!! 36 Carl 1 08/19/2001 09:51PM
Re: Can't believe what I read. 33 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 01:17AM
to each their own 29 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 01:59AM
Re: to each their own 34 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 02:34AM
we have different ears 41 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 02:36AM
Re: Marillion 38 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 02:47AM
maybe at the beginning 40 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 02:52AM
Re: Huh? 40 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 06:21AM
yeah 41 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 10:13AM
Re: we have different ears 43 John 08/22/2001 03:10AM
NJ's bands beat Chicago's! 41 sfk kurt 08/22/2001 03:14AM
I'm with you Kurt 37 Mike Matney 08/20/2001 08:30AM
Re: Sahara ??? 39 alex siedler 08/19/2001 07:52PM
Production-wise... 31 AOR Guru 08/20/2001 11:30AM
both are classics 42 sfk kurt 08/19/2001 09:48PM
Re: Overrated!!!!!!! 40Kauna08/20/2001 01:51AM
I'm LOLling! 38John Q08/20/2001 06:06AM
Re: best album of all-time 34riche galas08/19/2001 04:06PM
Re: best album of all-time 41 croman 08/19/2001 04:09PM
Re: best album of all-time 40 Carl 1 08/19/2001 09:58PM
Re: best album of all-time 38 Misterpomp 08/19/2001 05:46PM
Re: Sahara ??? 44 Ron (H) 08/19/2001 06:01PM
Re: Sahara ??? 32 Brian 08/19/2001 07:05PM
Re: Sahara ??? 40 Daniel 08/19/2001 09:09PM
Re: Sahara ??? 36 the ORIGINAL brent 08/19/2001 10:55PM
Re: Sahara ??? 41 Brian 08/20/2001 05:50AM
Re: best album of all-time 46 Carl 1 08/19/2001 10:05PM
Re: best album of all-time 33 Misterpomp 08/19/2001 10:17PM
Re: best album of all-time 34 Carl 1 08/20/2001 04:32AM
judging by this board - Lovemetal! 43 sfk kurt 08/19/2001 11:59PM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 44 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 12:47AM
cant believe what I just read! 42 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 02:34AM
Re: Not Really.. 32 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 02:42AM
but it's all ones taste innit? 48 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 02:50AM
Sorry ..54 Misterpomp 08/20/2001 03:30AM
depends on who you ask 30 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 10:17AM
a bit two faced, Kurt? 35 jennifer 08/20/2001 07:01AM
A word Jennifer 34 Misterpomp 08/20/2001 07:33AM
Re: A word Jennifer 39 Brian 08/20/2001 08:29AM
Re: A word Jennifer 44 jennifer 08/20/2001 08:31AM
Re: Jennifer 37 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 08:56AM
Re: Jennifer 37 jennifer 08/20/2001 09:39AM
Re: A word Jennifer 39 Misterpomp 08/20/2001 05:03PM
And you succeed brilliantly! 43 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 11:22PM
FU Jennifer 40 sfk kurt 08/20/2001 10:14AM
Re: a bit two faced, Kurt? 51 Mafia boy 08/21/2001 02:18PM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 34 Misterpomp 08/20/2001 03:27AM
Re: Better Floyd albums 39 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 06:37AM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 52 Carl 1 08/20/2001 04:46AM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 37 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 06:24AM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 37 Misterpomp 08/20/2001 07:35AM
Re: Carl's uhhh.... 36 Eric Abrahamsen 08/20/2001 07:52AM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 46 Carl 1 08/20/2001 08:17AM
Re: Pink Floyd / Radiohead 47 Carl 1 08/20/2001 08:14AM
re: Radiohead???? Gimme a break!!! 38Patrick08/20/2001 02:06AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.