Re: Why do people want Queen "back"???
Posted by: Doc K ()
Date: June 09, 2001 06:34AM

Few groups can withstand losing their lead throat, especially when there hasn't been a revolving door at the mic. I don't want Queen back without Freddie, and sorry as I am to say, don't want to listen to Journey without Perry, Styx without DeYoung, or Boston without Delp. The result of any effort to replace these singers is a lesser-than product which in effect, cashes in on the name of the band.

Some bands produce good music without the original. Tommy Shaw is a vital part of Styx (he just can't do it alone). Bad Co actually made a couple of good records without Paul Rodgers. And we all know the Van Halen story (to me, that is quite possibly the only situation of a singer coming in and the dynamics of the group being maintained.)

Since George Harrison's name has come up, I can say that one of the most hopeful things I can say about music from my generation is that quite possibly, McCartney and Harrison will drop the egos soon to collaborate on something. No, it wouldn't be the Beatles, but it'd be good to hear.

In a similar vein, we have Queen. I wouldn't begrudge Brian and Roger from playing Queen tunes under the name of another band, but I think Freddie, the music of the band and true fans are done a disservice by replacing him and continuing on.

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Why do people want Queen "back"??? 68 Misterpomp 06/09/2001 05:02AM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"??? 49 Brian 06/09/2001 05:36AM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"??? 46 Captain Can Man 06/09/2001 05:44AM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"??? 56 Captain Can Man 06/09/2001 05:42AM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"??? 58dave06/09/2001 05:49AM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"??? 48Surfpunk06/09/2001 06:04AM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"???56Doc K06/09/2001 06:34AM
in tribute of? 52 sfk kurt 06/09/2001 06:45AM
Successfully???? 44 Misterpomp 06/09/2001 08:35PM
Re: Successfully???? 51 sfk kurt 06/09/2001 09:52PM
Re: The Trick of Genesis 49 Eric Abrahamsen 06/09/2001 11:42PM
Not "back" but "forward"! 51 koogles 06/09/2001 09:35AM
That's my point ... 47 Misterpomp 06/09/2001 08:38PM
did you ever think... 58 sfk kurt 06/09/2001 09:53PM
Good point ... 64 Misterpomp 06/10/2001 02:03AM
Re: That's my point ... 50 Matt 06/10/2001 01:06PM
Re: That's my point ... 44 FORD 06/11/2001 01:59AM
Actually I'd disagree there ... 50 Misterpomp 06/11/2001 04:04AM
well it sure as @!#$ aint gonna be David Lee Hairp 50 sfk kurt 06/11/2001 04:30AM
since when is success... 47 sfk kurt 06/11/2001 04:37AM
Re: since when is success... 45 FORD 06/11/2001 11:57AM
Re: since when is success... 56 sfk kurt 06/11/2001 11:01PM
Re: since when is success... 47 FORD 06/12/2001 04:58AM
Re: since when is success... 52 sfk kurt 06/12/2001 05:32AM
Re: since when is success... 57 FORD 06/12/2001 02:31PM
Hey FORD! 48 Captain Can Man 06/12/2001 11:07AM
Re: Hey FORD! 51 FORD 06/13/2001 06:04AM
Re: since when is success... 50 ddregs 06/13/2001 06:13PM
Re: Why do people want Queen "back"??? 54 croman 06/11/2001 11:21PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.