This is only the second time...
Posted by: koogles ()
Date: April 25, 2001 02:44PM

... I've been terribly at odds with your reviews. (Melodica was the first time.) Because you ARE generally bang-on, Andrew, and my wallet does tend to open (or stay closed) based on what you deem a worthwhile listen or a waste of time, I thought I'd challenge the Asia "Aura" decision before it scared too many people away from what I perceive to be a decent piece of work. Believe it or not, your review mark does carry with it a certain amount of influence. (Case in point, I do not own the Smilek CD because of what you rated it!! Sorry, John Kivel!!)

Anyway, I didn't mean any offence by what I said. I was attacking your grade, not your grading criteria or even your condom-esque success rate at getting the job done neatly and without a lot of sloppy, sticky aftermath...

koogs

NP: Asia's 62 percenter

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 101 koogles 04/25/2001 06:07AM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 79 Richard 04/25/2001 06:14AM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 81 Jonte 04/25/2001 06:26AM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 78 Peter M. Bietenholz 04/25/2001 07:03AM
Hmmmm.... 80Surfpunk04/25/2001 07:12AM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 78 koogles 04/25/2001 07:52AM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 68Peter M. Bietenholz04/25/2001 04:42PM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 76mark kennedy04/25/2001 05:40PM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% (Whoops!!! 72mark kennedy04/25/2001 05:48PM
Thanks Mark! 71 Andrew 04/25/2001 07:02PM
Re: Thanks Mark! 79mark kennedy04/25/2001 10:57PM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 78 adolfo 04/25/2001 08:25AM
It kinds bugs me... 81 Andrew 04/25/2001 01:41PM
This is only the second time...85 koogles 04/25/2001 02:44PM
That's OK! 79 Andrew 04/25/2001 03:01PM
Re: Asia AURA: better than Andrew's 62% 73 Brian 04/25/2001 07:35PM
Best John Wetton-less Asia CD 80 koogles 04/25/2001 10:42PM
Re: Best John Wetton-less Asia CD 75Peter M. Bietenholz04/26/2001 12:30AM
Re: Best John Wetton-less Asia CD 65Dave04/26/2001 04:18AM
new Asia is AWFULA 82 The Other Joe 04/25/2001 10:56PM
Asia is not that h-aura-ble! 97 koogles 04/25/2001 11:17PM
New Asia remains awful. 69 The Other Joe 04/26/2001 03:22AM
Hey Joe... 71Surfpunk04/26/2001 04:02AM
Your Bret Michaels comparison remains awful 80 koogles 04/26/2001 08:39AM
Re: better than Andrew's 62% ? No 81 ddregs 04/26/2001 06:16PM
The key to appreciating Aura... 90 koogles 04/27/2001 12:03AM
The key to appreciating Aura... 66mark kennedy04/27/2001 05:08PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.