No. Not Marilyn Manson.
Posted by: Misterpomp ()
Date: February 05, 2001 04:23AM

I'm not sure which album cover might have lead you to believe this, only perhaps the make up on the latest "Believing is Seeing".
No, fortunately, Mr Valentine's work sounds much better than any of the names you mention (although I am fond of a little of each of those others). Queen is a very obvious reference point, Sparks too, Aviary, Elton John, Beatles, Abba... a very fine smorgasbord of influences.... all topped off with his own inimitable style .... the Queen thing has reared its head before (ie would he be a good replacement for Freddie). I think not. It's just my opinion but I think he writes better songs than Roger/John/Brian and if the three remaining members were to roll out a Queen gravy train they surely wouldn't want anybody else's name on the songwriting credits? I also think that most people would miss the point and they'd be accused of hiring a Mercury-alike. There are inlfluences but it's more much more than that. Still, it's a good game to play. If they're looking for somebody musically aligned (and a bit more), almost unknown and more their generation ... Brad Love???

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
Robby Valentine HELP... 121Kris02/04/2001 05:28PM
Re: Robby Valentine HELP... 93 Catman 02/04/2001 11:32PM
Re: Robby Valentine HELP... 93 chinese 02/05/2001 12:31AM
Re: what's he sound like ???????? 93 Rich 02/05/2001 02:23AM
Re: what's he sound like ???????? 93 Eric Abrahamsen 02/05/2001 03:48AM
Re: what's he sound like ???????? 84Mafia boy02/05/2001 08:44PM
No. Not Marilyn Manson.82 Misterpomp 02/05/2001 04:23AM
Re: Brad Love and Robbo 95 Eric Abrahamsen 02/05/2001 07:03AM
Re: Brad Love and Robbo 83Mafia boy02/05/2001 08:50PM
Re: Brad Love and Robbo 106 Eric Abrahamsen 02/05/2001 09:16PM
Re: Robby Valentine HELP... 92 Misterpomp 02/05/2001 04:25AM
Thanks to everyone!... 97Kris02/05/2001 06:33AM
Re: Robby Valentine HELP... 82 Carl 02/05/2001 09:02AM
Re: Brad Love and Robbo 82 Jordan in Jersey 02/07/2001 08:01AM
Re: Brad Love and Robbo 113 Eric Abrahamsen 02/07/2001 08:38AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.