RE: Asia and Magnum
Posted by: Eric Abrahamsen ()
Date: January 07, 2001 12:09AM

Payne is a terrible vocalist and Asia's material has been sub par for years. Paynes addition to the group has not helped matters, and I have not missed the band. Wetton on the other hand has talent to do wonderful things and I thought he was getting close with the reformation of UK an couple years ago, but that fell apart. "Battle Lines" just sounded to much like Asia. A guy with credentials like King Crimson, Uriah Heep, and UK can do better. Has anyone heard the work he did prior to Asia as vocalist for the French Prog group- Atoll?? Amazing stuff.

"Kingdom Of Madness" is one of the best UK AOR/Prog albums of any decade, and again I agree, after "The Eleventh Hour" things got a bit strange for Magnum. The early albums though are gems, and Magnum- IMHO ranks right up there with Kansas and Styx, and should have had equal sucsess.

Navigate: Previous MessageNext Message
Options: ReplyQuote


SubjectViewsWritten ByPosted
BOB CATLEY OR JOHN PAYNE ( who's in your heart ) ? 270 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/06/2001 12:51PM
RE: BOB CATLEY OR JOHN PAYNE ( who's in your heart 152 Mister Pomp 01/06/2001 06:58PM
RE: Asia and Magnum145 Eric Abrahamsen 01/07/2001 12:09AM
RE: Asia and Magnum 150 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 12:59AM
Hey! John Payne's an amazing singer! 172 koogles 01/07/2001 01:13AM
RE: Hey! John Payne's an amazing singer! 170 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 05:05AM
RE: Hey! John Payne's an amazing singer! 142 Eric Abrahamsen 01/07/2001 05:37AM
RE: Hey! John Payne's an amazing singer! 151 koogles 01/07/2001 05:58AM
RE: Hey! John Payne's an amazing singer! 165 Eric Abrahamsen 01/07/2001 06:43AM
If it's any consolation... 160 koogles 01/07/2001 08:55AM
I can now go public about the new Asia album... 150 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 07:17PM
Bands whose album titles grow tiresome 188 koogles 01/08/2001 12:38AM
RE: Bands whose album titles grow tiresome 160 Mister Pomp 01/08/2001 01:18AM
hahaha , nice try Mister Pomp , PATHETICAL !!! 181 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/08/2001 03:54AM
RE: hahaha , nice try Mister Pomp , PATHETICAL !!! 168 Mister Pomp 01/08/2001 06:58AM
RE: Go on with your life ... MR pomp !!! 199 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/08/2001 08:07AM
RE: Go on with your life ... MR pomp !!! 167Alex01/08/2001 10:00AM
RE: Come back to school , it/s getting late ALEX ! 147 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/08/2001 10:47AM
RE: Come back to school , it/s getting late ALEX ! 152Alex01/09/2001 03:03AM
RE: Wellcome to hell , MR English mann !!!!!!! 186 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/09/2001 07:42AM
Behave yourself! 145 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 07:22PM
RE: Hey! John Payne's an amazing singer! 171 Ron (Holland) 01/08/2001 02:30AM
RE: BOB CATLEY OR JOHN PAYNE ( who's in your heart 160 Francesco 01/06/2001 07:54PM
RE:Sorry folks , you/re the ones out of tune !!!!! 154 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/07/2001 02:33AM
Fave singers... 172 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 05:13AM
bollocks 152 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 05:16AM
RE: Fave singers... 128 koogles 01/07/2001 05:32AM
RE: COOL Koogs , that/s a man with good taste !! 162 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/07/2001 06:09AM
Now you're joking? 137 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 07:23PM
RE: Fave singers... 165 Lil Al 01/07/2001 09:01AM
No Mark free???? 131 chris 01/07/2001 12:02PM
Probably 169 Mister Pomp 01/07/2001 07:12PM
I'm lost for words 164Chris01/08/2001 12:06PM
Hmm 148 Chris 01/08/2001 12:07PM
RE: Fave singers... 144 Ron (Holland) 01/08/2001 02:51AM
RE: Fave singers... 142 Mister Pomp 01/08/2001 04:17AM
RE: Fave singers... 137 Ron (Holland) 01/08/2001 04:40AM
RE: Fave singers... 194 Mister Pomp 01/08/2001 06:48AM
RE: Fave singers... 155 Chris 01/08/2001 12:12PM
Vanity,??? 173 Ron (Holland) 01/09/2001 05:59AM
John Payne 141 RAMMY 01/07/2001 09:45PM
John Payne appears to be... 147 koogles 01/08/2001 01:15AM
He's no worse than, say, Robert Tepper 169 koogles 01/08/2001 01:19AM
Oh that's nasty ... 175 Mister Pomp 01/08/2001 07:01AM
John Payne has an coarse operatic style... 170 koogles 01/08/2001 11:07AM
RE: John Payne has an coarse operatic style... 158 Mister Pomp 01/08/2001 05:33PM
RE: Thanks RAMMY , you/ve surprised me !! 168 Melodic Lover ( SPAIN) 01/08/2001 04:52AM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Powered by Phorum.

Disclaimer: melodicrock.com takes no responsibility for the contents of messages posted on this open forum, or for the sanity of those posting.